TO CASH OR NOT CASH BUSINESS CHECKS

If you receive a payment from a debtor on business account and the words “acceptance of this check denotes payment in full” should you cash the check? The answer differs depending on the state law and the facts of the situation. One of the main issues in determining whether a satisfaction of a debt exists is whether there is a “bona fide” dispute between the parties regarding the amount owed. Generally, when there is a bona fide dispute between the parties as to the amount of a balance owing, one party can offer to pay a specific amount in full payment of that debt. The other party can accept the offer in cash or check — which is referred to as “accord and satisfaction”. This is essentially like a new contract. It should be noted that a dispute does not have to be based on a solid foundation but there must be some justification to it.

Note, however, that a business who receives such a check may not simply cross out the language and write “under protest” in order to get around the “accord and satisfaction” concept.

It should also be noted that while some companies process thousands of checks, nevertheless, some courts have held that when a creditor’s accounting department cashes a debtor’s check in ignorance that it was an attempt to “accord and satisfaction”, a subsequent timely protest by the creditor defeated a finding of that “accord and satisfaction”. In some states, however, where a claim is disputed and a check is offered for settlement, the retention of a check constitutes an “accord and satisfaction” settlement regardless of any protest by the creditor. Also, under Uniform Commercial Code 3-311 a creditor has the right to revoke an “accord and satisfaction”.